Make your money go further for just 25p per day

Help to Buy: has it worked?

A man on top of a house building the roof
Half of the houses built by Persimmon last year were bought via the government’s Help-to-Buy scheme. But critics say the initiative has created a housing bubble and that housebuilders’ bumper profits are undeserved. Could this lead to an unwinding of the scheme?

Annual results from Persimmon (LSE: PSN) confirm it: Help-to-Buy has been a boon for the housebuilders. The FTSE 100 group’s profit per house has trebled since the scheme was introduced in 2013 and last year, return on average capital employed rose to almost 53%. That means that for every £1 invested, the company is making 53p back – an almost unheard-of figure. In 2012 (the year before the scheme was introduced), the group generated an average return on capital employed of just 12%.

These figures are starting to make people uncomfortable about the Help-to-Buy scheme: who is really benefiting from an initiative which has sucked up £20bn of taxpayer money to date?

The answer depends on who you ask.

By the end of 2018, almost 200,000 property purchases had been completed under the scheme, helping many young buyers who otherwise may not have been able to get onto the housing ladder. Of the 16,449 houses Persimmon built last year, 7,970 were bought…

Sign up and read the full article

Register to continue reading this article.

Get FREE access now

Already a member? Login

Have your say

Log in or register to view or add comments.

For access to the top news and insights from the investment world

REGISTER FREE TODAY

Become a Champion Investor for as little as £3.20 per report or get a year's worth of money-making analysis for just £90.

SUBSCRIBE NOW

More on Barratt Developments

Dividend dogs vs diamonds: Part 1 – beware the yield

21/05/2019 · Investors Clinic

A high yielding dividend might be very tempting to investors seeking a little extra income, but…


Help to Buy: has it worked?

26/02/2019 · Money Management
Half of the houses built by Persimmon last year were bought via the government’s Help-to-Buy scheme.…

UK Housebuilders: bargain or value trap?

15/01/2019 · Investors Clinic
The longevity of the Help-to-Buy scheme and the potential impacts of Brexit have weighed on sentiment…

Bargain UK housebuilders, but which should you go for?

28/12/2018 · Company research

More on Bovis Homes Group

Dividend dogs vs diamonds: Part 1 – beware the yield

21/05/2019 · Investors Clinic

A high yielding dividend might be very tempting to investors seeking a little extra income, but…


Help to Buy: has it worked?

26/02/2019 · Money Management
Half of the houses built by Persimmon last year were bought via the government’s Help-to-Buy scheme.…

UK Housebuilders: bargain or value trap?

15/01/2019 · Investors Clinic
The longevity of the Help-to-Buy scheme and the potential impacts of Brexit have weighed on sentiment…

Bargain UK housebuilders, but which should you go for?

28/12/2018 · Company research

More on Persimmon

Dividend dogs vs diamonds: Part 1 – beware the yield

21/05/2019 · Investors Clinic

A high yielding dividend might be very tempting to investors seeking a little extra income, but…


Michelmersh is an ideal stock: yield, growth and IHT qualifying

26/04/2019 · Investors Clinic

Established in 1997, Michelmersh Brick Holdings (LON:MBH) comprises six of the UK’s premium brands of…


If Help-to-Buy comes under pressure, there is always Build-to-Rent

28/02/2019 · News & Insights
Amid the controversy surrounding super-profitable housebuilders which have been boosted by the government’s help-to-buy scheme, Telford…

Help to Buy: has it worked?

26/02/2019 · Money Management
Half of the houses built by Persimmon last year were bought via the government’s Help-to-Buy scheme.…

UK Housebuilders: bargain or value trap?

15/01/2019 · Investors Clinic
The longevity of the Help-to-Buy scheme and the potential impacts of Brexit have weighed on sentiment…

More on Redrow

Help to Buy: has it worked?

26/02/2019 · Money Management
Half of the houses built by Persimmon last year were bought via the government’s Help-to-Buy scheme.…

Redrow dividend seems as safe as houses

19/02/2019 · Portfolio
Few companies divide investor opinion as strongly as the UK's housebuilders. Are the super-sized dividend yields…

UK Housebuilders: bargain or value trap?

15/01/2019 · Investors Clinic
The longevity of the Help-to-Buy scheme and the potential impacts of Brexit have weighed on sentiment…

Bargain UK housebuilders, but which should you go for?

28/12/2018 · Company research

More on Taylor Wimpey

Michelmersh is an ideal stock: yield, growth and IHT qualifying

26/04/2019 · Investors Clinic

Established in 1997, Michelmersh Brick Holdings (LON:MBH) comprises six of the UK’s premium brands of…


Brexit: one month to prepare your portfolio

09/03/2019 · Investors Clinic
With one month to go, businesses are still worried about the potential of leaving the EU…

Help to Buy: has it worked?

26/02/2019 · Money Management
Half of the houses built by Persimmon last year were bought via the government’s Help-to-Buy scheme.…

UK Housebuilders: bargain or value trap?

15/01/2019 · Investors Clinic
The longevity of the Help-to-Buy scheme and the potential impacts of Brexit have weighed on sentiment…

Bargain UK housebuilders, but which should you go for?

28/12/2018 · Company research

More Money Management

Robo-wars: Investec axes Click & Invest

16/05/2019

Busting the myths of the independent financial adviser industry

09/05/2019

Brexit is bad for business, is a delay worse?